Vegans Are Getting B12 Wrong: Here's What Actually Works

I'll say it straight: most vegans are playing Russian roulette with their B12 status, and the supplement industry is cashing in on their confusion. I've seen too many patients—bright, health-conscious people—walk into my office with fatigue, brain fog, or worse, because they believed the myth that fermented foods or occasional nutritional yeast could cover their needs. It's not their fault; there's a ton of bad information out there. But after working with hundreds of vegans over the years, I can tell you that getting B12 right isn't complicated—it just requires ignoring the noise and following what the science actually says.

What's in This Article

• Why B12 Isn't Optional—It's Non-Negotiable
• How Your Body Uses (or Loses) B12
• The Dosing Reality Most Brands Get Wrong
• What to Take (and What to Trash)
• 7 Mistakes I See Vegans Make Every Day
• My Honest Take: What Most Articles Won't Tell You
• Your Questions, Answered
• Key Takeaways

This Isn't Just About Energy—It's About Preventing Damage

B12 deficiency doesn't just make you tired. It can quietly damage your nervous system for years before you notice anything's wrong. I had a patient, a 32-year-old graphic designer who'd been vegan for eight years, come in complaining of "pins and needles" in her hands. She'd been taking a "vegan multivitamin" with 10 mcg of B12—way too low—and her serum B12 was at 180 pg/mL, well below the 300 pg/mL cutoff I consider safe. After six months of proper supplementation, her symptoms improved, but she'll likely have some residual nerve sensitivity. That's the scary part: some effects aren't fully reversible.

Here's what adequate B12 actually does for you. It helps produce red blood cells, so you don't become anemic. It maintains the myelin sheath around your nerves—think of it as the insulation on an electrical wire. When that breaks down, signals get fuzzy. It's also involved in DNA synthesis and energy production at the cellular level. The RDA is 2.4 mcg daily, but that's for people who absorb it efficiently from food. Vegans need a different approach because there's zero B12 in plants unless they're fortified.

Your Gut Is the Gatekeeper—and It's a Picky One

B12 absorption is a multi-step process that can go wrong at several points. First, you need stomach acid to cleave B12 from protein in animal foods—but since vegans aren't getting it from food, that step is irrelevant. Then, intrinsic factor, a protein made in your stomach, binds to B12 and escorts it through the small intestine for absorption. Only about 1-2% of free B12 (from supplements) gets absorbed passively without intrinsic factor, which is why high doses are necessary. As you age, stomach acid and intrinsic factor production decline, making absorption even trickier.

Conditions like celiac disease, Crohn's, or atrophic gastritis (common in older adults) can slash absorption. Medications like metformin for diabetes or proton pump inhibitors for acid reflux also interfere. That's why I always ask new patients about their meds and gut health—it changes everything.

The Forms That Matter (and One That Doesn't)

You'll see three main forms: cyanocobalamin, methylcobalamin, and adenosylcobalamin. Cyanocobalamin is synthetic, stable, and cheap—it's what's in most fortified foods and budget supplements. Your body converts it to the active forms (methyl and adenosyl), but some people, especially those with MTHFR gene variants, do this poorly. Methylcobalamin is the active form that crosses into cells directly. Adenosylcobalamin is another active form involved in energy production. I prefer methylcobalamin for most people because it's ready to use.

Forget the RDA—Here's What You Really Need

The RDA of 2.4 mcg is meaningless for vegans because it assumes you're absorbing B12 from food. Since you're not, you need doses 100 to 1,000 times higher to compensate for low absorption. The European Food Safety Authority recommends at least 4 mcg daily for adults, but that's still too low for passive absorption. Here's my practical dosing guide, based on what I've seen work in clinic.

• Daily maintenance: 250-500 mcg of cyanocobalamin OR 1,000 mcg of methylcobalamin. Yes, that's a huge difference—methylcobalamin is less stable, so you need more.
• Weekly option: 2,500 mcg of cyanocobalamin or methylcobalamin once a week. This works because the passive absorption pathway doesn't saturate easily.
• If you're deficient: Start with 1,000-2,000 mcg daily for 1-2 months, then drop to maintenance. Get your levels checked after three months.
• Timing: Take it with a meal—any meal. The old idea that you need it on an empty stomach is a myth. Consistency matters more.

Sublingual (under the tongue) tablets or sprays can be useful if you have gut absorption issues, but they're not necessary for everyone. I've had patients swear by them, but the research isn't conclusive—oral high-dose works fine for most.

My Shelf vs. The Trash Can

I'm picky about brands because I've seen too many fail third-party testing. Here's what I recommend—and what I tell patients to avoid.

What I Recommend (and Why)

• Thorne Methylcobalamin (1,000 mcg): This is my go-to for most vegans. It's pure methylcobalamin, no fillers, and Thorne's quality control is impeccable. I've used it for years, and it consistently raises blood levels in my patients.
• Jarrow Formulas Methyl B12 (1,000 mcg, lozenge): A more affordable option that still uses methylcobalamin. The lozenge form dissolves slowly, which may enhance absorption. Jarrow is reliable and widely available.
• NOW Foods B-12 (1,000 mcg, cyanocobalamin): If budget is tight, this is a solid choice. Cyanocobalamin works for most people, and NOW Foods is USP verified, meaning it's been tested for purity and potency.

What I'd Avoid

• Generic Amazon brands with names like "Vegan B12 Boost" or "Super B12 Complex." ConsumerLab found that 40% of these didn't contain the labeled amount—some had none at all. You're gambling with your health.
• Brands with proprietary blends that don't disclose exact amounts. If the label says "B12 blend 500 mg" without breaking it down, skip it. You have no idea what you're getting.

7 Mistakes That Keep Vegans Deficient

1. Relying on nutritional yeast or fermented foods: Some brands fortify nutritional yeast with B12, but many don't—and the amount varies wildly. Fermented foods like tempeh or miso have trace amounts at best, not enough to meet needs.
2. Taking too low a dose: A multivitamin with 10 mcg of B12 is useless for vegans. You need hundreds of micrograms.
3. Not testing levels: I recommend vegans get a serum B12 test annually. Homocysteine and methylmalonic acid are better markers but more expensive. Don't guess—test.
4. Stopping when you feel better: B12 stores can last years, so deficiency creeps up slowly. Once you're replete, you still need maintenance for life.
5. Ignoring other nutrients: B12 works with folate and iron. A vegan diet can be low in iron, so check that too. I've seen patients fix B12 but still feel tired because their iron was low.
6. Assuming all supplements are equal: They're not. Quality varies dramatically. Stick with third-party tested brands.
7. Waiting for symptoms: By the time you feel tired or tingly, you might already have nerve damage. Prevention is easier than repair.

My Honest Take: The Vegan Community Needs a Reality Check

I used to think cyanocobalamin was fine for everyone—it's what I learned in school. But after seeing patients with MTHFR variants struggle on it, I've switched to recommending methylcobalamin as the first choice. It costs more, but it works better for more people. The research on this is still evolving, but my clinical experience has convinced me.

Another controversial opinion: I don't think most vegans need B12 injections unless they're severely deficient or have absorption issues. Oral high-dose works for 90% of people, and injections are expensive and inconvenient. Save them for when oral fails.

Your Questions, Answered

Q: Can I get B12 from algae or seaweed?
No. Some algae contain B12 analogs that can interfere with real B12 absorption. They're not reliable sources. Stick to supplements or fortified foods.

Q: How long does it take to correct a deficiency?
It depends on severity. With high-dose supplements, you might feel better in weeks, but it can take 3-6 months to replenish stores fully. Get retested after three months to track progress.

Q: Is there a risk of taking too much B12?
B12 is water-soluble, so excess is excreted in urine. No upper limit has been set because toxicity is rare. That said, megadoses (like 5,000 mcg daily) aren't necessary and can be wasteful. Stick to the doses I recommended.

Q: What's the best form for seniors?
Methylcobalamin, because aging reduces stomach acid and intrinsic factor. A sublingual form might help, but a high-dose oral methylcobalamin (1,000 mcg daily) usually works. I've had patients in their 70s do well on Thorne's version.

Q: Do I need to take B12 with other B vitamins?
Not necessarily, but a B-complex can be helpful because B vitamins work together. If you're taking a separate B12, make sure your diet includes folate (from leafy greens) and B6 (from whole grains). A 2020 study in the Journal of Dietary Supplements found that vegans taking B12 alone still improved levels, but adding a B-complex helped with energy markers slightly more.

Q: Can medications affect B12 absorption?
Yes. Metformin (for diabetes) reduces absorption by up to 30%. Proton pump inhibitors (like omeprazole) and H2 blockers (like ranitidine) decrease stomach acid, which can impair B12 release from food—but since vegans aren't getting B12 from food, this matters less for supplements. If you're on these meds, consider a higher dose (e.g., 1,500 mcg daily) and monitor levels closely. I had a patient on metformin who needed 2,000 mcg daily to maintain optimal levels.

What to Do Next